Inside the Agency: What Government Buyers Want Suppliers to Know
November 17, 2026Most suppliers know the RFP side of government contracting well: finding opportunities, reading requirements, writing responses. Far fewer get to see what happens on the other side of the table.
That was the focus of our recent webinar, Inside the Agency: What Government Buyers Want Suppliers to Know, hosted by Derrick Koenig, Vice President of Product Management at SOVRA.
The session brought together two former government procurement leaders:
- Trevor Day, former Procurement Commissioner for the City of Philadelphia, who led the charter change that allowed best-value RFPs and sat on dozens of evaluation committees.
- Valerie Bollinger, former Chief Procurement Officer for the State of Idaho and 2024 NASPO president, who ran procurements ranging from heavy equipment to multi-billion-dollar Medicaid and health insurance contracts.
Here’s a high-level look at what they shared.
Myth-busting: Do bigger firms really have the advantage?
When we polled attendees on the biggest myth about government bidding, the top answer was that bigger firms have an advantage. Valerie’s take: from a process standpoint, no. Anyone can compete, and great suppliers tend to rise to the top.
The nuance is logistics. A statewide contract may require capacity a small business can’t offer yet. Her advice is to look for right-sized opportunities, and to consider subcontracting or reselling as a way to build toward larger bids.
What if an RFP looks unfair? Both speakers agreed: raise it during the process, not after.
- Ask early. Procurement teams want a fair process, but they aren’t experts in everything they buy. A narrow specification may simply have slipped through.
- Propose a fix. Tell the buyer what you’d like changed, not just what’s wrong.
- Use Q&A wisely. Trevor noted agencies now receive hundreds of questions per solicitation. Use AI to sharpen your questions, not to multiply them.
What happens before the RFP is published
Three-quarters of attendees said they first hear about an opportunity when the RFP is published. By then, a lot of the thinking has already happened.
Trevor walked through how a purchase takes shape. The end-user agency defines the need, since they’re the subject matter experts. The procurement office safeguards fairness, transparency, competition and best value for taxpayers. Aligning the two takes time, and RFIs often feed directly into the final RFP.
Relationships help, but proposals win. Valerie was candid here. Knowing an agency helps you understand its needs and timing. But the person you know may not be an evaluator, and evaluation committees score what’s on the page against published criteria. An award based on a strong proposal is defensible if challenged; one based on a relationship is not. Trevor’s reframe: treat outreach as education, not sales. Agencies want to learn about industry best practices.
Read budgets as a guide, not a price tag. Budget documents and hearings are a great early signal of what’s coming. They can also tell you which tier of solution an agency can afford. But a budget line often covers more than the contract itself, such as consultants or new staff. Never use it to set your price; you’re still in a competition.
What separates a compliant response from a winning one
Valerie used to tell her evaluators that a 10 out of 10 should leave “socks on the floor.” A compliant response answers every question and meets the minimums. A winning response gives evaluators confidence you’ll deliver. What gets you there:
- Show you understand their situation. Reference their market, goals and constraints, not a generic template. (A proposal to Idaho that mentions Ohio does not land well.)
- Skip the marketing fluff. Evaluators spot it, and they dislike it. Give concrete results, data and relevant KPIs instead.
- Bring innovation. Incumbents lose more often than people think, usually by proposing the status quo. Trevor shared how a challenger in Philadelphia won a camera maintenance contract by proposing full replacement, which ultimately lowered the city’s maintenance costs.
- Proofread your AI. Whatever your proposal promises can end up in your contract.
The most avoidable mistake, according to Trevor, is missing a basic requirement. Bid bonds, insurance, experience thresholds and required forms vary by jurisdiction. A strong response disqualified over one missing document frustrates the agency as much as the supplier. Pick a focused set of target agencies and learn their rules.
Valerie explains exactly how she trained evaluators to score a 10 — and the red flags that sunk otherwise strong proposals — in the full session. Watch it free on demand →
When you lose a bid, start learning
No one wins them all. Both speakers urged suppliers to treat a loss as the start of the next win.
- Take the debrief if it’s offered. Ask where your proposal fell short and where it lacked detail. Note that timing varies; some agencies wait until a final award.
- Dig into the record. Evaluator comments and public records requests can reveal more about how a decision was made.
- Learn, don’t litigate. Valerie’s advice is to use the debrief to improve, not to pick apart the decision.
- Stay engaged. Attend vendor outreach days and industry events, and check in with agencies between contract cycles.
Watch the full conversation on demand
The takeaway is simple: understand the agency, write a proposal that stands on its own, and keep learning from every bid. This recap covers the headline lessons, but a good chunk of the session can’t be summarized:
- Trevor’s and Valerie’s stories from inside Philadelphia and Idaho — including the camera contract upset and what a multi-billion-dollar Medicaid procurement teaches about preparation
- Every audience poll result, including the ones that surprised the panel
- The complete live Q&A, from AI in evaluations to whether pilots lead to sole-source awards
Watch Inside the Agency: What Government Buyers Want Suppliers to Know on demand →